| 6 | DL Bairstow | Warwickshire v Yorkshire | 1978 | f32146 |
| 5 | M Sherwin | A Shaw's Australian Team v L Hall's XI | 1885 | f2961 |
| 5 | AFA Lilley | Yorkshire v Warwickshire | 1895 | f4215 |
| 5 | D Hunter | Surrey v Yorkshire | 1898 | f4895 |
| 5 | D Hunter | Warwickshire v Yorkshire | 1901 | f5647 |
| 5 | A Dolphin | Derbyshire v Yorkshire | 1919 | f9387 |
| 5 | JL Ellis | Yorkshire v Australians | 1926 | f11571 |
| 5 | A Wood | Northamptonshire v Yorkshire | 1934 | f14579 |
| 5 | A Wood | Worcestershire v Yorkshire | 1934 | f14769 |
| 5 | A Wood | Indians v Yorkshire | 1946 | f17197 |
| 5 | LH Compton | Yorkshire v Middlesex | 1951 | f19243 |