| 5 | AFA Lilley | West Indians v England XI | 1906 | f6971 |
| 5 | G Duckworth | England XI v Lancashire | 1925 | f11415 |
| 5 | B Taylor | Lancashire v Essex | 1958 | f22451 |
| 5 | APE Knott | Lancashire v Kent | 1964 | f25431 |
| 5 | LD Sutton | Warwickshire v Lancashire | 2006 | f49504 |
| 4 | J Shields | Australians v England XI | 1909 | f7810 |
| 4 | JM Parks | Lancashire v Sussex | 1960 | f23451 |
| 4 | TG Evans | North v South | 1961 | f23984 |
| 4 | RW Taylor | Lancashire v Derbyshire | 1969 | f27866 |
| 4 | EW Jones | Lancashire v Glamorgan | 1970 | f28328 |
| 4 | FM Engineer | Glamorgan v Lancashire | 1970 | f28328 |
| 4 | G Sharp | Lancashire v Northamptonshire | 1974 | f30240 |
| 4 | FM Engineer | Leicestershire v Lancashire | 1975 | f30682 |
| 4 | T Frost | Lancashire v Warwickshire | 1997 | f43186 |