| 4 | TR Ambrose | Worcestershire v Warwickshire | 2009 | tt1252 |
| 4 | MGK Burgess | Yorkshire v Warwickshire | 2021 | tt9791 |
| 3 | GD Cross | Leicestershire v Lancashire | 2011 | tt2369 |
| 3 | TR Ambrose | Yorkshire v Warwickshire | 2015 | tt4981 |
| 3 | JC Buttler | Warwickshire v Lancashire | 2017 | tt6374 |
| 3 | TR Ambrose | Lancashire v Warwickshire | 2018 | tt7138 |
| 3 | BD Guest | Warwickshire v Derbyshire | 2021 | tt9750 |
| 3 | T Banton | Hampshire v Somerset | 2021 | tt10011 |