| 5 | GHS Garton | Derbyshire v Warwickshire | 2025 | tt15230 |
| 4 | AM Rahane | England v India | 2014 | tt4506 |
| 4 | JB Lintott | Northamptonshire v Warwickshire | 2020 | tt9018 |
| 4 | JJ Weatherley | Warwickshire v Hampshire | 2022 | tt11092 |
| 4 | JL du Plooy | Lancashire v Derbyshire | 2023 | tt12186 |
| 4 | MAH Hammond | Sussex v Gloucestershire | 2024 | tt14167 |