| 4 | AL Wadekar | England v India | 1967 | t620 |
| 4 | HP Tillakaratne | England v Sri Lanka | 2002 | t1605 |
| 3 | IT Botham | India v England | 1979 | t851 |
| 3 | PH Edmonds | Australia v England | 1985 | t1021 |
| 3 | NV Knight | India v England | 1996 | t1327 |
| 3 | GP Thorpe | New Zealand v England | 1999 | t1455 |
| 3 | WW Hinds | England v West Indies | 2000 | t1500 |
| 3 | ME Waugh | England v Australia | 2001 | t1550 |
| 3 | PD Collingwood | Sri Lanka v England | 2006 | t1803 |
| 3 | HM Amla | England v South Africa | 2008 | t1883 |
| 3 | AJ Strauss | Pakistan v England | 2010 | t1969 |
| 3 | AJ Strauss | West Indies v England | 2012 | t2045 |
| 3 | AC Voges | England v Australia | 2015 | t2173 |
| 3 | CT Bancroft | England v Australia | 2019 | t2353 |
| 3 | Z Crawley | India v England | 2022 | t2470 |
| 3 | Z Crawley | India v England | 2022 | t2470 |