| 6 | JD Carr | Warwickshire v Middlesex | 1995 | f41726 |
| 5 | TS Fishwick | South Africans v Warwickshire | 1904 | f6372 |
| 5 | WE Bates | Warwickshire v Glamorgan | 1928 | f12253 |
| 5 | AF Wensley | Warwickshire v Sussex | 1932 | f13916 |
| 5 | JA Jameson | Indians v Warwickshire | 1971 | f28793 |
| 5 | AC Storie | Leicestershire v Warwickshire | 1988 | f37669 |
| 5 | NV Knight | Warwickshire v Essex | 1994 | f41194 |
| 5 | M van Jaarsveld | Warwickshire v Kent | 2007 | f50180 |