| 5 | ADS Fletcher | West Indies Under-19s v Windward Islands | 2016/17 | a25097 |
| 5 | JN Hamilton | West Indies Under-19s v Leeward Islands | 2016/17 | a25143 |
| 5 | I Khaleel | Kent v United States of America | 2017/18 | a26156 |
| 4 | BB McCullum | West Indies v New Zealand | 2006/07 | a18154 |
| 4 | PA Patel | West Indies v India | 2011 | a21392 |
| 4 | CS Baugh | India v West Indies | 2011 | a21393 |
| 4 | EWJA Stewart | Windward Islands v West Indies Under-19s | 2016/17 | a25097 |
| 4 | SW Ambris | West Indies Under-19s v Windward Islands | 2016/17 | a25138 |
| 4 | SD Hope | India v West Indies | 2017 | a25683 |
| 4 | IP Kishan | West Indies A v India A | 2019 | a27458 |
| 4 | CAK Walton | West Indies Emerging Players v Jamaica | 2022/23 | a29539 |