| 5 | D Ramdin | New Zealand v West Indies | 2014 | t2125 |
| 4 | FCM Alexander | England v West Indies | 1959/60 | t488 |
| 4 | DM Lewis | India v West Indies | 1970/71 | t686 |
| 4 | TM Findlay | New Zealand v West Indies | 1971/72 | t697 |
| 4 | DL Murray | India v West Indies | 1975/76 | t774 |
| 4 | DA Murray | Australia v West Indies | 1977/78 | t823 |
| 4 | KS More | West Indies v India | 1988/89 | t1119 |
| 4 | PJL Dujon | India v West Indies | 1988/89 | t1119 |
| 4 | RC Russell | West Indies v England | 1989/90 | t1142 |
| 4 | PJL Dujon | England v West Indies | 1989/90 | t1142 |
| 4 | JR Murray | Australia v West Indies | 1994/95 | t1296 |
| 4 | D Williams | England v West Indies | 1997/98 | t1399 |
| 4 | RD Jacobs | Australia v West Indies | 1998/99 | t1448 |
| 4 | D Ramdin | Sri Lanka v West Indies | 2007/08 | t1872 |
| 4 | SO Dowrich | Sri Lanka v West Indies | 2018 | t2306 |
| 4 | JM Da Silva | India v West Indies | 2023 | t2513 |