| 6 | ED Solkar | West Indies v India | 1970/71 | t683 |
| 5 | GS Sobers | England v West Indies | 1959/60 | t491 |
| 5 | RC Fredericks | Australia v West Indies | 1972/73 | t721 |
| 5 | AJ Lamb | West Indies v England | 1989/90 | t1142 |
| 5 | BC Lara | England v West Indies | 1993/94 | t1257 |
| 5 | ML Hayden | West Indies v Australia | 2002/03 | t1639 |