| 4 | SS Karim | West Indies v India | 1996/97 | o1201 |
| 4 | MV Boucher | West Indies v South Africa | 2000/01 | o1717 |
| 4 | PA Patel | West Indies v India | 2011 | o3160 |
| 4 | MS Dhoni | Sri Lanka v India | 2013 | o3388 |
| 3 | PJL Dujon | New Zealand v West Indies | 1984/85 | o327 |
| 3 | IA Healy | West Indies v Australia | 1990/91 | o672 |
| 3 | RD Jacobs | Australia v West Indies | 1998/99 | o1439 |
| 3 | RD Jacobs | Pakistan v West Indies | 1999/00 | o1595 |
| 3 | RD Jacobs | India v West Indies | 2001/02 | o1837 |
| 3 | AC Gilchrist | West Indies v Australia | 2002/03 | o2019 |
| 3 | KC Sangakkara | Bermuda v Sri Lanka | 2006/07 | o2534 |
| 3 | MS Dhoni | Bangladesh v India | 2006/07 | o2538 |
| 3 | MS Dhoni | Sri Lanka v India | 2006/07 | o2550 |
| 3 | D Ramdin | South Africa v West Indies | 2010 | o2987 |
| 3 | KD Karthik | Sri Lanka v India | 2013 | o3387 |
| 3 | KC Sangakkara | India v Sri Lanka | 2013 | o3388 |
| 3 | MS Dhoni | West Indies v India | 2017 | o3896 |