| 4 | AG Prince | West Indies v South Africa | 2004/05 | o2244 |
| 4 | E Chigumbura | West Indies v Zimbabwe | 2006 | o2373 |
| 3 | CEL Ambrose | Pakistan v West Indies | 1987/88 | o509 |
| 3 | CL Hooper | Australia v West Indies | 1990/91 | o672 |
| 3 | JC Adams | Sri Lanka v West Indies | 1995/96 | o1096 |
| 3 | DM Bravo | Sri Lanka v West Indies | 2013 | o3385 |
| 3 | V Kohli | West Indies v India | 2019 | o4197 |
| 3 | S Dhawan | West Indies v India | 2022 | o4439 |