| 4 | DO Christian | Windward Islands v Guyana | 2004/05 | a16208 |
| 4 | JR Murray | Trinidad and Tobago v Windward Islands | 2005/06 | a16873 |
| 4 | DO Christian | Trinidad and Tobago v Guyana | 2005/06 | a16891 |
| 4 | Hamza Tariq | Barbados v ICC Americas | 2016/17 | a25129 |
| 4 | Hamza Tariq | Combined Campuses and Colleges v ICC Americas | 2016/17 | a25144 |
| 4 | SD Hope | Combined Campuses and Colleges v Barbados | 2017/18 | a26033 |
| 3 | DO Christian | Leeward Islands v Guyana | 2005/06 | a16875 |
| 3 | CS Baugh | England A v West Indies A | 2005/06 | a17355 |
| 3 | TT Walcott | Hampshire v Barbados | 2017/18 | a26121 |