| 4 | MS Dhoni | Afghanistan v India | 2010 | tt1694 |
| 4 | DC Thomas | St Lucia Stars v St Kitts and Nevis Patriots | 2018 | tt7160 |
| 3 | Kamran Akmal | Australia v Pakistan | 2010 | tt1717 |
| 3 | AO Thomas | Guyana v Jamaica | 2012/13 | tt3299 |
| 3 | CS Baugh | St Lucia Zouks v Jamaica Tallawahs | 2013 | tt3790 |
| 3 | ADS Fletcher | Barbados Tridents v St Lucia Zouks | 2016 | tt5853 |
| 3 | N Pooran | Australia v West Indies | 2021 | tt9823 |
| 3 | Q de Kock | Trinbago Knight Riders v Barbados Royals | 2022 | tt11343 |
| 3 | K Lewis | St Lucia Kings v Jamaica Tallawahs | 2022 | tt11344 |
| 3 | H Klaasen | St Lucia Kings v Guyana Amazon Warriors | 2022 | tt11356 |