| 4 | DM de Silva | West Indies v Sri Lanka | 2018 | t2308 |
| 4 | PWA Mulder | West Indies v South Africa | 2021 | t2424 |
| 4 | JO Holder | South Africa v West Indies | 2021 | t2426 |
| 3 | BC Lara | Sri Lanka v West Indies | 2003 | t1648 |
| 3 | Shamsur Rahman | West Indies v Bangladesh | 2014 | t2139 |
| 3 | ST Gabriel | Bangladesh v West Indies | 2014 | t2139 |
| 3 | KC Brathwaite | India v West Indies | 2016 | t2215 |
| 3 | JO Holder | Sri Lanka v West Indies | 2018 | t2308 |
| 3 | BA Stokes | West Indies v England | 2018/19 | t2346 |
| 3 | JE Root | West Indies v England | 2018/19 | t2346 |
| 3 | HE van der Dussen | West Indies v South Africa | 2021 | t2424 |
| 3 | AK Markram | West Indies v South Africa | 2021 | t2424 |
| 3 | D Elgar | West Indies v South Africa | 2021 | t2426 |
| 3 | J Blackwood | Bangladesh v West Indies | 2022 | t2468 |