| 4 | DJ Bravo | Canada v Trinidad and Tobago | 2010 | tt1875 |
| 4 | DC Thomas | Barbados Tridents v Antigua Hawksbills | 2013 | tt3772 |
| 3 | MEK Hussey | Bangladesh v Australia | 2010 | tt1702 |
| 3 | Nawroz Mangal | South Africa v Afghanistan | 2010 | tt1703 |
| 3 | HH Gibbs | New Zealand v South Africa | 2010 | tt1705 |
| 3 | CP Wood | Trinidad and Tobago v Hampshire | 2010/11 | tt2076 |
| 3 | JM Vince | Trinidad and Tobago v Hampshire | 2010/11 | tt2087 |
| 3 | KA Pollard | St Lucia Zouks v Barbados Tridents | 2013 | tt3767 |
| 3 | KA Pollard | Antigua Hawksbills v Barbados Tridents | 2013 | tt3772 |
| 3 | KA Pollard | Trinidad and Tobago Red Steel v Barbados Tridents | 2013 | tt3775 |
| 3 | DR Smith | St Kitts and Nevis Patriots v Barbados Tridents | 2015 | tt4998 |
| 3 | CJ Green | Barbados Tridents v Guyana Amazon Warriors | 2018 | tt7183 |
| 3 | SE Rutherford | Barbados Tridents v Guyana Amazon Warriors | 2019 | tt8191 |
| 3 | CR Brathwaite | Barbados Tridents v St Kitts and Nevis Patriots | 2019 | tt8202 |
| 3 | JO Holder | St Lucia Zouks v Barbados Tridents | 2019 | tt8205 |
| 3 | RA Jadeja | Afghanistan v India | 2024 | tt13835 |
| 3 | R Powell | St Kitts and Nevis Patriots v Barbados Royals | 2024 | tt14172 |