| 4 | MR Marsh | West Indies v Australia | 2016 | o3752 |
| 3 | AL Logie | New Zealand v West Indies | 1984/85 | o328 |
| 3 | IVA Richards | India v West Indies | 1988/89 | o556 |
| 3 | GP Thorpe | West Indies v England | 1993/94 | o880 |
| 3 | MA Taylor | West Indies v Australia | 1994/95 | o985 |
| 3 | AJ Hollioake | West Indies v England | 1997/98 | o1301 |
| 3 | JC Adams | Australia v West Indies | 1998/99 | o1441 |
| 3 | DJG Sammy | England v West Indies | 2008/09 | o2828 |
| 3 | PR Stirling | West Indies v Ireland | 2019/20 | o4229 |