| 6-24 | CM Willoughby | South Africa A v Barbados | 2000 | a12916 |
| 5-10 | SP Narine | Trinidad and Tobago v Combined Campuses and Colleges | 2017/18 | a25975 |
| 5-16 | AC Cummins | Barbados v Leeward Islands | 1993/94 | a8460 |
| 5-17 | MD Marshall | Barbados v Guyana | 1990/91 | a6907 |
| 5-18 | AJ Hall | South Africa v England | 2006/07 | a18183 |
| 5-18 | A Jordan | Combined Campuses and Colleges v Trinidad and Tobago | 2018/19 | a26872 |
| 5-22 | J Garner | Barbados v Leeward Islands | 1976/77 | a1850 |
| 5-24 | MLC Foster | Jamaica v Barbados | 1975/76 | a1594 |
| 5-26 | FD Stephenson | Barbados v Jamaica | 1981/82 | a3246 |
| 5-26 | FD Stephenson | Barbados v Guyana | 1989/90 | a6397 |
| 5-26 | JL Carter | Barbados v Windward Islands | 2012/13 | a22550 |
| 5-30 | SK Springer | Barbados v Jamaica | 2018/19 | a26842 |
| 5-33 | JS Louis | Leeward Islands v Barbados | 2018/19 | a26747 |
| 5-35 | LJ Griffin | Leeward Islands v Barbados | 1975/76 | a1591 |
| 5-37 | AC Cummins | Barbados v Jamaica | 1995/96 | a9453 |
| 5-38 | MD Marshall | Barbados v Guyana | 1982/83 | a3555 |
| 5-38 | KA Stoute | Barbados v Leeward Islands | 2018/19 | a26817 |
| 5-39 | HR Walsh | West Indies v Australia | 2021 | a28454 |
| 5-40 | JE Taylor | Jamaica v Guyana | 2016/17 | a25101 |
| 5-46 | SS Cotterell | West Indies v England | 2018/19 | a27026 |
| 5-48 | MA Starc | Australia v West Indies | 2021 | a28454 |
| 5-50 | JR Hazlewood | Australia v West Indies | 2016 | a24810 |
| 5-60 | S Mahmood | North v South | 2017/18 | a26331 |
| 5-62 | CK Langeveldt | South Africa v West Indies | 2004/05 | a16620 |
| 5-64 | CEI Bartlette | Leeward Islands v Barbados | 1984/85 | a4310 |