| 3 | DJG Sammy | New Zealand v West Indies | 2012 | o3289 |
| 3 | DJG Sammy | Bangladesh v West Indies | 2014 | o3514 |
| 2 | HH Gibbs | Australia v South Africa | 2006/07 | o2552 |
| 2 | DJ Bravo | Australia v West Indies | 2008 | o2734 |
| 2 | DBL Powell | Australia v West Indies | 2008 | o2736 |
| 2 | JR Hopes | West Indies v Australia | 2008 | o2736 |
| 2 | Mohammad Ashraful | West Indies v Bangladesh | 2009 | o2865 |
| 2 | CH Gayle | New Zealand v West Indies | 2012 | o3288 |
| 2 | NL McCullum | West Indies v New Zealand | 2012 | o3288 |
| 2 | LRPL Taylor | West Indies v New Zealand | 2012 | o3289 |
| 2 | MJ Guptill | West Indies v New Zealand | 2012 | o3289 |
| 2 | BB McCullum | West Indies v New Zealand | 2012 | o3290 |
| 2 | RJ Nicol | West Indies v New Zealand | 2012 | o3290 |
| 2 | MJ Guptill | West Indies v New Zealand | 2012 | o3290 |
| 2 | DJG Sammy | New Zealand v West Indies | 2012 | o3290 |
| 2 | Nasir Hossain | West Indies v Bangladesh | 2014 | o3514 |
| 2 | KAJ Roach | Bangladesh v West Indies | 2014 | o3514 |
| 2 | HM Amla | Australia v South Africa | 2016 | o3743 |
| 2 | F Behardien | West Indies v South Africa | 2016 | o3747 |
| 2 | KOA Powell | Bangladesh v West Indies | 2018 | o4024 |