| 5 | DD Boxill | Combined Leeward and Windward Islands v Barbados | 1969/70 | f28110 |
| 5 | SJ Rixon | Leeward Islands v Australians | 1977/78 | f31967 |
| 4 | BN Jarman | Leeward Islands v Australians | 1964/65 | f25690 |
| 4 | A Hector | Guyana v Leeward Islands | 1968/69 | f27633 |
| 4 | TM Findlay | Barbados v Combined Leeward and Windward Islands | 1973/74 | f29949 |
| 4 | MC Neita | Combined Leeward and Windward Islands v Jamaica | 1980/81 | f33436 |
| 4 | JK Silva | West Indies A v Sri Lanka A | 2006/07 | f49665 |
| 4 | JN Hamilton | Barbados v Leeward Islands | 2014/15 | f56273 |