| 5 | WR Logan | South Americans v Scotland | 1932 | f13947 |
| 5 | RT Webb | Scotland v Marylebone Cricket Club | 1959 | f22782 |
| 5 | RJ Campbell | Scotland v Australia A | 1998 | f43818 |
| 5 | BJ Haddin | Scotland v Australia A | 2013 | f54873 |
| 4 | G MacGregor | Australians v Scotland | 1905 | f6685 |
| 4 | TA Ward | Scotland v South Africans | 1912 | f8585 |
| 4 | WP Hone | Scotland v Ireland | 1913 | f8908 |
| 4 | WAS Oldfield | Scotland v Australians | 1934 | f14725 |
| 4 | AK McTavish | Ireland v Scotland | 1936 | f15405 |
| 4 | J Firth | Scotland v Yorkshire | 1950 | f18816 |
| 4 | K Fiddling | Scotland v Northamptonshire | 1951 | f19189 |
| 4 | J Brown | Pakistanis v Scotland | 1954 | f20485 |
| 4 | Shakoor Ahmed | Scotland v Pakistanis | 1954 | f20485 |
| 4 | J Brown | Ireland v Scotland | 1966 | f26419 |