| 6 | JH du Preez | Transvaal v Rhodesia | 1974/75 | f30482 |
| 5 | DD Dyer | Transvaal B v Natal B | 1968/69 | f27659 |
| 5 | HR Lance | Natal v Transvaal | 1970/71 | f28503 |
| 5 | EJ Barlow | Transvaal v Western Province | 1976/77 | f31357 |
| 5 | HR Fotheringham | Natal v Transvaal | 1978/79 | f32377 |
| 5 | B Dudleston | Transvaal v Rhodesia | 1978/79 | f32407 |
| 5 | RG Pollock | West Indies XI v South Africa | 1983/84 | f35042 |
| 5 | MJ Mitchley | Natal B v Transvaal B | 1987/88 | f37379 |
| 5 | KR Rutherford | Northerns v Gauteng | 1997/98 | f43515 |
| 5 | DN Crookes | KwaZulu-Natal v Gauteng | 1998/99 | f43973 |
| 5 | AM Bacher | Boland v Gauteng | 1998/99 | f44203 |
| 5 | AM Phangiso | Gauteng v Northerns | 2007/08 | f50603 |
| 5 | JH Kallis | Australia v South Africa | 2008/09 | f51475 |
| 5 | RR Rossouw | Lions v Knights | 2013/14 | f55493 |
| 5 | S von Berg | Lions v Titans | 2017/18 | f58160 |