| 6 | AD Nourse | Border v Natal | 1933/34 | f14474 |
| 6 | VY Richardson | South Africa v Australia | 1935/36 | f15274 |
| 6 | KS McEwan | Natal v Western Province | 1982/83 | f34365 |
| 6 | SM Pollock | Boland v KwaZulu-Natal | 1999/00 | f44585 |
| 6 | HH Dippenaar | Dolphins v Eagles | 2007/08 | f50227 |
| 6 | CH Morris | Dolphins v Lions | 2014/15 | f56309 |
| 6 | SSB Magala | Dolphins v Warriors | 2019/20 | f59801 |
| 5 | IDE Anderson | Orange Free State v Natal | 1937/38 | f16002 |
| 5 | WR Hammond | South Africa v England | 1938/39 | f16415 |
| 5 | GG Ritchie | Natal v Transvaal | 1962/63 | f24659 |
| 5 | RN Ireland | Western Province v Natal B | 1967/68 | f27105 |
| 5 | MB Madsen | Border v Natal B | 1974/75 | f30363 |
| 5 | KA McKenzie | Natal v Transvaal | 1977/78 | f31790 |
| 5 | WJ van der Linden | Natal B v Transvaal B | 1978/79 | f32406 |
| 5 | DK Pearse | Northern Transvaal B v Natal B | 1982/83 | f34552 |
| 5 | ST Jefferies | Natal v Western Province | 1987/88 | f37280 |
| 5 | BM McMillan | Natal v Transvaal | 1987/88 | f37380 |
| 5 | DN Crookes | Northamptonshire v Natal | 1991/92 | f39870 |
| 5 | BM White | Natal v Border | 1996/97 | f42635 |
| 5 | CR Wilson | KwaZulu-Natal v Boland | 1999/00 | f44585 |
| 5 | JM Kemp | Dolphins v Cape Cobras | 2010/11 | f52915 |
| 5 | DPMD Jayawardene | South Africa v Sri Lanka | 2011/12 | f53705 |
| 5 | K Nipper | KwaZulu-Natal v KwaZulu-Natal Inland | 2011/12 | f53731 |
| 5 | MJ Ackerman | Northerns v KwaZulu-Natal | 2017/18 | f58414 |
| 5 | AB de Villiers | Australia v South Africa | 2017/18 | f58553 |