| 4 | HM Amla | Pakistan v South Africa | 2013/14 | o3441 |
| 3 | KC Wessels | Pakistan v South Africa | 1992/93 | o806 |
| 3 | JH Kallis | West Indies v South Africa | 1998/99 | o1404 |
| 3 | JP Duminy | Sri Lanka v South Africa | 2009/10 | o2893 |
| 3 | JP Duminy | New Zealand v South Africa | 2009/10 | o2895 |
| 3 | AB de Villiers | Sri Lanka v South Africa | 2016/17 | o3834 |