| 6 | W Bossenger | Northern Transvaal v Griqualand West | 1996/97 | a10086 |
| 6 | HG Kuhn | Warriors v Titans | 2008/09 | a19229 |
| 5 | I Mitchell | Northerns v Border | 1997/98 | a10744 |
| 5 | G Morgan | Boland v Northerns | 1998/99 | a11531 |
| 5 | MV Boucher | New Zealand v South Africa | 2005/06 | a16954 |
| 5 | MN van Wyk | Titans v Eagles | 2006/07 | a17695 |
| 5 | TD Paine | England v Australia | 2009/10 | a20028 |
| 5 | HG Kuhn | Lions v Titans | 2009/10 | a20259 |
| 5 | HG Kuhn | Lions v Titans | 2016/17 | a25219 |
| 5 | HG Kuhn | Cape Cobras v Titans | 2016/17 | a25373 |
| 5 | C Fortuin | Titans v Warriors | 2017/18 | a25957 |