| 4 | NL McCullum | Auckland v Otago | 2004/05 | f48534 |
| 4 | C de Grandhomme | Otago v Auckland | 2012/13 | f54615 |
| 4 | DN Phillips | Central Districts v Otago | 2020/21 | f60354 |
| 3 | CL Bull | Otago v Canterbury | 1983/84 | f35043 |
| 3 | RJ Nicol | Otago v Auckland | 2004/05 | f48534 |
| 3 | NT Broom | Otago v Canterbury | 2004/05 | f48561 |
| 3 | NL McCullum | Wellington v Otago | 2007/08 | f50724 |
| 3 | NR Parlane | Otago v Wellington | 2008/09 | f51495 |
| 3 | CD Cumming | Central Districts v Otago | 2010/11 | f53058 |
| 3 | LRPL Taylor | South Africa v New Zealand | 2011/12 | f53904 |
| 3 | GC Smith | New Zealand v South Africa | 2011/12 | f53904 |
| 3 | HD Rutherford | England v New Zealand | 2012/13 | f54690 |
| 3 | HD Rutherford | Canterbury v Otago | 2013/14 | f55354 |
| 3 | NT Broom | Northern Districts v Otago | 2013/14 | f55456 |
| 3 | JDS Neesham | Northern Districts v Otago | 2015/16 | f56953 |
| 3 | BS Wilson | Northern Districts v Otago | 2016/17 | f57844 |
| 3 | SC Kuggeleijn | Otago v Northern Districts | 2016/17 | f57844 |
| 3 | LJ Carter | Otago v Canterbury | 2018/19 | f59116 |
| 3 | JS Patel | Otago v Wellington | 2018/19 | f59378 |
| 3 | DN Phillips | Central Districts v Otago | 2019/20 | f60114 |
| 3 | GR Hay | Otago v Central Districts | 2020/21 | f60354 |
| 3 | AK Kitchen | Northern Districts v Otago | 2020/21 | f60368 |
| 3 | GD Phillips | Otago v Auckland | 2021/22 | f60689 |
| 3 | MJG Rippon | Wellington v Otago | 2022/23 | f61460 |
| 3 | JA Duffy | Canterbury v Otago | 2022/23 | f61482 |
| 3 | JM Cumming | Central Districts v Otago | 2023/24 | f61819 |
| 3 | SM Solia | Otago v Auckland | 2023/24 | f62165 |