| 5 | ER Caygill | Otago v Canterbury | 1910/11 | f8145 |
| 5 | JR Lamason | Otago v Wellington | 1937/38 | f16045 |
| 5 | EA Watson | Canterbury v Otago | 1953/54 | f20341 |
| 5 | GS Chappell | Otago v Australians | 1976/77 | f31474 |
| 5 | SJ McCullum | Auckland v Otago | 1987/88 | f37319 |
| 5 | KJ Burns | Northern Districts v Otago | 1990/91 | f39249 |
| 4 | WEP Barnes | Otago v Canterbury | 1885/86 | f2964 |
| 4 | ACK Mackenzie | Otago v New South Wales | 1893/94 | f3987 |
| 4 | RDW Barry | Otago v Canterbury | 1900/01 | f5493 |
| 4 | KM Ollivier | Otago v Canterbury | 1904/05 | f6520 |
| 4 | KM Ollivier | Otago v Canterbury | 1906/07 | f7045 |
| 4 | A Sims | Otago v Canterbury | 1910/11 | f8145 |
| 4 | RC Blunt | Otago v Canterbury | 1920/21 | f9812 |
| 4 | FT Badcock | Otago v Wellington | 1925/26 | f11458 |
| 4 | HN Lambert | Otago v Wellington | 1927/28 | f12213 |
| 4 | LA Clark | Canterbury v Otago | 1958/59 | f22518 |
| 4 | KW Hough | Otago v Auckland | 1959/60 | f23035 |
| 4 | WP Bradburn | Otago v Northern Districts | 1959/60 | f23038 |
| 4 | JH Shaw | New Zealand v Australia | 1959/60 | f23124 |
| 4 | WJR Haskell | Otago v Wellington | 1962/63 | f24635 |
| 4 | BAG Murray | Otago v Wellington | 1964/65 | f25653 |
| 4 | JT Sparling | Otago v Auckland | 1969/70 | f28043 |
| 4 | KO Campbell | Auckland v Otago | 1969/70 | f28043 |
| 4 | GS Chappell | Otago v Australians | 1969/70 | f28134 |
| 4 | GM Turner | Wellington v Otago | 1970/71 | f28504 |
| 4 | GM Turner | Auckland v Otago | 1971/72 | f28963 |
| 4 | NM Parker | Otago v Canterbury | 1975/76 | f30887 |
| 4 | GB Thomson | Auckland v Otago | 1975/76 | f30911 |
| 4 | PH Edmonds | Otago v England XI | 1977/78 | f31962 |
| 4 | BL Cairns | West Indies v New Zealand | 1979/80 | f32953 |
| 4 | GJ Dawson | Canterbury v Otago | 1981/82 | f33934 |
| 4 | JG Bracewell | Otago v Auckland | 1986/87 | f36852 |
| 4 | PW Dobbs | Indians v Otago | 1989/90 | f38552 |
| 4 | RA Lawson | Canterbury v Otago | 1992/93 | f40388 |
| 4 | RS Mahanama | New Zealand v Sri Lanka | 1996/97 | f42981 |
| 4 | SR Mather | Auckland v Otago | 1999/00 | f44996 |
| 4 | BB McCullum | Auckland v Otago | 2001/02 | f46221 |